Full List of our free My first time gay stories

 

Total: 425

 

First time cock to cock 9.00: vote

Two friends discover more about each other the hard way...

Added: 02-May-2016

Rating: 9.00
Read...
First Time Anal Virginity 7.95: vote

Anal virginity Taken...

Added: 02-Jul-2014

Rating: 7.95
Read...
Wagner Park 8.33: vote

Young man discovers rest stop sex...

Added: 08-Oct-2016

Rating: 8.33
Read...
Mouth-to-Cock Resuscitation 9.19: vote

First Aid teacher takes my anal cherry...

Added: 02-Sep-2013

Rating: 9.19
Read...
How my first time happens 2.66: vote

I was over at a friend"s house watching a movie...

Added: 20-Mar-2017

Rating: 2.66
Read...
Eighteenth Birthday Night! 7.56: vote

Newly legal, I"m taken to a club to experience all the gay scene has to offer. Hot men, hot sex, and warm cum abound...

Added: 16-Mar-2017

Rating: 7.56
Read...
My first time with an older man I met online 2.00: vote

First time I met up with someone and shared a gay experience...

Added: 17-Dec-2014

Rating: 2.00
Read...
My first time taming a monster 6.50: vote

I meet two guys at a truckstop near Modesto where they both fucked me...

Added: 23-Jan-2017

Rating: 6.50
Read...
A Very Good Boy 8.33: vote

My first time with a man is far more than I ever dreamed!

Added: 23-Oct-2014

Rating: 8.33
Read...
Never going back. 9.67: vote

My first time, my mind as made up...

Added: 26-Nov-2015

Rating: 9.67
Read...
My first gay experience 3.00: vote

My first time with a male...

Added: 01-Nov-2017

Rating: 3.00
Read...
Sexy Asian Boy - Gary 3.50: vote

My first time with Gary, a sexy Asian student...

Added: 25-Jun-2015

Rating: 3.50
Read...
6 Months 4.60: vote

He flipped around to be on his back and saw on what he had tripped; Alex’s naked body was lying on ground, naked, cold, lifeless...

Added: 16-Jun-2013

Rating: 4.60
Read...
Of Course, Craigslist! 7.60: vote

A first time doesn"t start with love, but rather with raw lust...

Added: 12-Jun-2013

Rating: 7.60
Read...
Coach... 5.67: vote

My freshman year coach reunion...

Added: 28-Sep-2013

Rating: 5.67
Read...
The Day I"ve Been Waiting For 6.78: vote

A story About my first time with my Best friend who I always fantasized about...

Added: 11-Aug-2014

Rating: 6.78
Read...
My First Fuck 7.07: vote

True story of my first gay experience. To top or bottom? I think I picked the right position...

Added: 22-Jan-2015

Rating: 7.07
Read...
First Time with Jonny 7.17: vote

My first time with Johnny...

Added: 31-Aug-2013

Rating: 7.17
Read...
My First time with SCam 8.00: vote

I had a meeting with a know gay attorney. I didnt know that this was going to happen...

Added: 25-Jun-2016

Rating: 8.00
Read...
Mystery Threesome 9 6.00: vote

Matthew tries to talk to Richard about their first gay sexual experience and David spreads the news of his engagement, when the unknown mystery student is yet again suffering from another attack...

Added: 03-Sep-2015

Rating: 6.00
Read...
My first time turns into a threesome 6.80: vote

A first time suck turns into a double team fuck...

Added: 18-Jun-2016

Rating: 6.80
Read...
Farm Hands 9.37: vote

Hiring help has its appeal. Or so Evan finds out after a steamy encounter with the new farm hand...

Added: 02-Jun-2013

Rating: 9.37
Read...
The Thirst Within : Chapter 3 6.60: vote

Zak meets his maker and Oscar has an interesting dream...

Added: 17-Oct-2013

Rating: 6.60
Read...
First taste : Blowjob swallowing - Part 2 9.33: vote

I could feel my heart beating in my throat as I very nervously approached. I knew that in the next sixty seconds I was going to be on my knees with a strangers cock in my mouth. I could see that he wasn"t fully hard yet but he was touching himself in an effort to get hard...

Added: 29-Sep-2016

Rating: 9.33
Read...
Boy Gets Two Big Loads 7.48: vote

Boy gets into trouble with an older man he meets online. Ends up paying for it...

Added: 09-Nov-2017

Rating: 7.48
Read...
My first time made me ... fabulous! 8.50: vote

It began as a someone who thought he was "straight but curious" answering an ad in aGayMen.com for someone who "enjoyed taking men on their maiden voyage!" What happened was - thoroughly - unexpected!

Added: 07-Aug-2016

Rating: 8.50
Read...
Two Wrestlers Have Sex 8.50: vote

Two wrestlers get a little drunk and my buddy pops my cherry...

Added: 21-Oct-2015

Rating: 8.50
Read...
He Blew Me, I Blew Him 8.75: vote

Two men find themselves in an instance where oral is their best relief...

Added: 25-Dec-2014

Rating: 8.75
Read...
Me and my friend Justin 5.25: vote

Me and my friend have some fun...

Added: 22-Sep-2013

Rating: 5.25
Read...
My First Time Fucking With Guy 5.50: vote

The story of my first time with another man...

Added: 04-May-2016

Rating: 5.50
Read...
Curiosity and first time 8.87: vote

This story is about how I came to love secretly being a bitch...

Added: 18-Oct-2013

Rating: 8.87
Read...
First Nude Beach Experience 9.39: vote

This is a true story about my first time on a nude beach...

Added: 13-Dec-2016

Rating: 9.39
Read...
My first time with Dashonne 7.54: vote

I lose my gay virginity after a basketball game...

Added: 22-Aug-2013

Rating: 7.54
Read...
My first threesome, with two older guys! 8.33: vote

A typical internet hookup quickly turns into something way more...

Added: 07-Mar-2014

Rating: 8.33
Read...
Trent 6.70: vote

My first time was my senior year in high school. I had a friend, Trent who ""even though was a senior was a year older than me. I stay the night at his ""house...

Added: 26-Jul-2016

Rating: 6.70
Read...
First gay massage with a very happy ending 9.22: vote

Needing a massage I found a guy in the paper that does "male only" massages, making an appointment for what I thought could be more than just a massage...

Added: 03-Feb-2017

Rating: 9.22
Read...
My first time after waiting for months! 9.14: vote

My first experience with another guy after waiting for months!

Added: 19-Oct-2015

Rating: 9.14
Read...
I WANT TO Find A Man With A Boat 6.67: vote

What I would do if I found a man with a boat...

Added: 02-Mar-2017

Rating: 6.67
Read...
One Love: Part One 7.99: vote

Chris is at high school and somethings happen and everything just starts going downhill from there. He finds out some very interesting news...

Added: 14-Sep-2013

Rating: 7.99
Read...
Blindfolded : Swallowing and Rimming story 8.78: vote

Well, I was at Lewis’s house yesterday and he led me blindfolded into his bedroom. He put me on the bed and in seconds I was sucking his cock. Man, he has a nice cock. It’s just the right size and shape to go right down my throat. I love having him push my mouth all the way down on his cock...

Added: 01-Oct-2016

Rating: 8.78
Read...
Sleeping over at Chris"s 7.85: vote

My first time with a boy...

Added: 29-Mar-2017

Rating: 7.85
Read...
My 1st gay experience 8.25: vote

An unexpected gay encounter...

Added: 09-Oct-2017

Rating: 8.25
Read...
The Cabin 5 8.75: vote

Something is troubling Logan and someone"s Ex comes up to the cabin...

Added: 21-Jul-2014

Rating: 8.75
Read...
Austin"s Best 8.50: vote

This is a story of me and a now close friend named Austin...

Added: 29-Sep-2014

Rating: 8.50
Read...
A Late Night At Work 3.00: vote

A university security guard gets ravished by sexy college teens...

Added: 01-May-2014

Rating: 3.00
Read...
My first time, gay sex with friend at pool 6.71: vote

I was 22 he was 21, we were both horny and curious...

Added: 23-Feb-2019

Rating: 6.71
Read...
PJ 4.00: vote

Hooking up with an older sexy man named PJ...

Added: 08-Oct-2015

Rating: 4.00
Read...
First time in the locker room 9.28: vote

Losing my cherry to my dream guy in the locker room...

Added: 18-Jan-2014

Rating: 9.28
Read...
My First Glory Hole 6.00: vote

My first anonymous cock will forever remain in my memory. I have accepted my insane disposition, and now I can be myself...

Added: 03-Jan-2017

Rating: 6.00
Read...
A first Time Twice 5.00: vote

My first time with a man and My first time in a video booth...

Added: 16-May-2016

Rating: 5.00
Read...
Callum & Jason 1 8.86: vote

Callum is getting ready for school after his quick wank in the shower, but has a quick encounter with his friend Jason in his room when he comes to pick him up...

Added: 27-Apr-2014

Rating: 8.86
Read...
My first experience 8.57: vote

How did I end up here? Am I dreaming? Well... it seems not!

Added: 21-Jan-2019

Rating: 8.57
Read...
A day at Steves bathhouse 7.37: vote

It was my first time going to a bathhouse and didn"t know what to expect...

Added: 18-Nov-2016

Rating: 7.37
Read...
My fantasy 7.33: vote

I got up on my knees sideways in the seat and took his cock in one hand, holding it between my thumb and fore finger. It was the first time I"d ever touched another man’s cock. Taking a deep breath, I leaned over to put my face in his lap and bumped my head on his steering wheel...

Added: 02-Oct-2016

Rating: 7.33
Read...
My First Ever Gay Sex 6.50: vote

Fiction, my first time having gay sex, the details and feelings...

Added: 15-Nov-2016

Rating: 6.50
Read...
He Was Better 8.86: vote

The day after my first time with my best friend, I go out on a date with a guy and plans change for the better...

Added: 13-Aug-2014

Rating: 8.86
Read...
How I lost my cheery hitchhiking 9.22: vote

My first time with a older man, forced to obey, older younger...

Added: 07-Dec-2014

Rating: 9.22
Read...
Working Up the Nerve 8.33: vote

A fictional account of first time gay sex...

Added: 20-Feb-2017

Rating: 8.33
Read...
What Its Like To Be A Real Bottom 8.77: vote

This story is how years of training my hole pay off when I finally decide to be fucked. How my hole changes and how it effects the cock it’s wrapped around...

Added: 22-Feb-2019

Rating: 8.77
Read...
I picked the wrong door 6.43: vote

I went to a gloryhole, for a BJ and I pick the wrong door, but it all worked out, anyway...

Added: 28-May-2014

Rating: 6.43
Read...
About My First Time 9.22: vote

After thinking about what sex with a guy would be like for some time, an online chat and invite to meet turned into having my first time with a guy...

Added: 03-Feb-2017

Rating: 9.22
Read...
First time experience 3.57: vote

My first time with my mate who"s now my lover...

Added: 30-Jul-2014

Rating: 3.57
Read...
Massuer Teases Me 8.33: vote

I"ve had my masseur for more than a year. But I didn"t expect that he would lead me on into something that would change his massage forever...

Added: 05-Jul-2014

Rating: 8.33
Read...
My first time having cock. 6.75: vote

I had waited too long and needed to have what I have been waiting for...

Added: 05-Jul-2017

Rating: 6.75
Read...
First Time with dream boy Aaron 7.33: vote

I have my first time in the changing room on sports day...

Added: 17-Nov-2014

Rating: 7.33
Read...
My First In and At Love 9.00: vote

High School Grad"s First Ever Love...

Added: 01-Apr-2016

Rating: 9.00
Read...
My first time in Africa 5.11: vote

I felt sad as we started the last week of the project. Continuation...

Added: 17-May-2018

Rating: 5.11
Read...
Really fun night 6.83: vote

Well, I always wondered what it would be like to suck a dick, I never acted on ""it...

Added: 24-Mar-2017

Rating: 6.83
Read...
Mario"s true self 7.13: vote

My first time with my cousin...

Added: 24-Dec-2013

Rating: 7.13
Read...
Topping it Out 8.29: vote

Me and my friend Anthony are having rough patches in our current relationships and what better way to solve them by me topping him...

Added: 07-Sep-2014

Rating: 8.29
Read...
First 6.43: vote

His name was Brock and there he sat on my couch, barefoot, dressed in kaki cargo pants and a tight blue t-shirt. I noticed his eyes wandering towards me. I was just in Levis shorts and a white T-shirt...

Added: 24-Oct-2016

Rating: 6.43
Read...
Lockdown loving 6.40: vote

Sex behind bars...

Added: 08-Mar-2014

Rating: 6.40
Read...
My first time was hot! 8.50: vote

I went on and took a shower because I had sand all over my skin, he just came in and I was like "What do you want now?" I couldn"t even finish that sentence and he directly kissed me without saying anything...

Added: 07-Oct-2014

Rating: 8.50
Read...
The Cabin 2 9.50: vote

As the night goes on up at the family cabin, Brian is making his move to make sure that this night is a night to remember... Fiction!

Added: 03-Oct-2013

Rating: 9.50
Read...
My first time with an older man 7.56: vote

This is the story of when I became an older mans stress reliever and sex slave...

Added: 09-Jul-2014

Rating: 7.56
Read...

 

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 [>>]

Hop to:
Search
Random The Blue Yonder : Part One.

On a long haul through the galaxy to New Earth, the 3rd generation crew starts to feel very differently towards eachother. But why?

Read...